Fine opening -the music has time and space and the sound has depth - well controlled playing. Timp a little "weak" into 5 - bass duet fine. Some good playing into grazioso - cornet just needs to relax a little more at 7. Good playing at 8 - good approach through to 9 - well balanced sounds -super euphonium. Effective into 10. Nice flugal voice - just slightly nervous(a pity). Lovely accomps and again well balanced sympathetic accomps to all the solo lines - well shaped. Tuning just waivers a little at 12 but the music flows. Thoughtful playing into 13 - just the odd blemish at slowest but the music has atmosphere. Fine at moderato - music has poise. Good at 15 - again the music has lots of space. Effective into 17 - not all detail heard however. V good at 18 - some dynamics - Thanks! Allegro has atmosphere and playing is controlled - slightly loose into 22 and again well controlled playing into 25 - but side drum not really convincing -closing bars have impact.
A performance with lots of merit - a VERY musical approach throughout. Thank you.
James Scott
A very good opening - with attention to detail and balance. Basses manage 5 well, and there is space given after this, where there are many good moments of ensemble. 8 splendid and shapely playing cornet, and this continues with some detailed band playing. Well done flugal at lento, and the accompaniment is well balanced. At 12 cornets are not quite in tune(in melodic line) - but I like the flow in phrasing that is achieved. 13 quite well managed, even if there is a hint of uneasiness. The moderato begins well, and space is given to allow clarity, and the changes in momentum are achieved well. Only the odd moment of unease before 22 - but generally you have very good control of the final pages of the score.
A performance that had much to commend - and well well directed.
1. Stockbridge, D. Nesbitt, 11
2. Glossop Old, J. Davies, 5
3. Bo'ness & Carriden, M. Marzella, 1
4. Bactiguard Wire Brass, P. Andrews, 17
5. Powerfuel Hatfield Colliery, G. O'Conner, 12
6. United Norwest Co-op Milnrow, A. White, 18
7. Parc & Dare, C. Roberts, 6
8. Newtongrange, I. Fleming, 2
9. United Co-op Crewe, J. Sparkes, 13
10. Mossley, D. Bryers, 4
11. United Norwest Co-op Yorkshire Brass, W. Rushworth, 10
12. Blackburn and Darwen, N. Sheppard, 8
13. Friary Guildford, C. King, 3
14. Marsden Riverhead Brewery, G. Williams, 9
15. Tavistock Chester le Street Riverside, I. Robinson, 20
16. Old Silkstone, A. Exley, 19
17. Drighlington, K. Belcher, 7
18. Vernon Building Society, A. Lawton, 16
19. Harrogate, D. Lancaster, 14
20. Longridge, P. Lockett, 15
Top four bands qualify for the Senior Cup
Soloist prize: Solo cornet, Bo'ness & Carriden
]]>I saw this on the 4barsrest site though it may be of interest to everone. any comments welcome here, but also to [email protected]
]]>